New information Kinlochmoidart 2 and MacDonalds are Simple

The following has been noted about Lament for MacDonald of Kinlochmoidart 2 and the MacDonalds are Simple

Kinclochmoidart no 2

In V2 singling and doubling line 1 repeat Angus MacKay and Binneas have BC not AC before hiharin/taorlauth beats. MacKay has this in line 3, Binneas does not.  BC is more consistent with the suibhal.  See full judges’ note.

Macdonalds are Simple

Binneas has a Taorluath a mach in this tune, the only publication to have this.  See full judges’ note.